Choosing between keeping my messy outline or starting fresh, and the outline won
I've been working on a short story about a guy who fixes clocks for a living, and I hit a wall at about 2,000 words last Tuesday. I had this messy outline full of arrows and crossed out lines, and I kept going back and forth on whether to scrap it and start clean or push through with what I had. I ended up picking the messy outline because my wife pointed out I'd already written down 14 little scene ideas in the margins. So I sat down at the kitchen table in Boise and just followed the scribbles for two hours straight. The draft is rough, the ending makes no sense yet, and one character changes her name halfway through. But I got 1,100 new words out of it, which is more than I'd gotten in the past week. The whole thing feels like a pile of loose parts right now. Has anyone else had luck sticking with a beat up outline instead of starting over? I'm curious if it actually saves time or just hides the real problem.
Keeping the messy outline probably saved you from the trap of a "clean" restart, which is really just procrastination in a nicer font. Those 14 margin scenes are gold because they came from a fired-up brain, not a careful one. Here's the thing nobody talks about: the outline isn't the problem, it's a map of where your brain already went, so tossing it means you lose the trail. Follow the scribbles till the draft is done, then clean up the name slip and the bad ending in the second pass.