G
31

A judge in a small claims court told me something I never knew about evidence...

I was in a courtroom in Springfield last week for a dispute over a $500 security deposit. I brought all my photos and texts, but the other guy had a printed email I'd forgotten about. The judge looked at me and said, 'If it's not in front of me, it didn't happen.' He meant that you have to bring a physical copy of everything, even digital stuff. I lost because I assumed showing things on my phone was enough. Now I print every single text and email before any hearing. Has anyone else gotten tripped up by a simple rule like that?
3 comments

Log in to join the discussion

Log In
3 Comments
hill.jade
hill.jade2mo ago
A printed email? That seems so outdated for a modern court. You'd think showing the original on your phone would be more reliable than a paper copy. It's frustrating when the system doesn't keep up with how we actually live.
3
blair396
blair3962mo ago
Yeah, "showing the original on your phone" sounds right until you've been the person fumbling to unlock it with a judge watching. My own tech skills would probably get the email deleted by accident. It is a system built for paper, hill.jade, so we're stuck with the printer for now.
1
taylor174
taylor1741mo ago
300 bucks and a formal reprimand is what I got for showing a digital receipt that the judge couldn't zoom in on. @hill.jade I get your point about it feeling outdated, but a printed page can't run out of battery or accidentally swipe away.
3