7
Finally compared audiobooks vs print for my club's pick on Wednesday
I read 'Project Hail Mary' on paper while my friend listened to the audiobook. The audio version has a part where the alien communicates through musical tones that just doesn't work the same on the page. Has anyone else found a book that's clearly better in one format over the other?
2 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In2 Comments
thea_chen6h ago
That musical tones part in Project Hail Mary is a great example. For me, horror books like "World War Z" are way creepier as audiobooks since the voice acting sells the panic way harder than reading it.
1
averym823h ago
Disagree completely. I tried World War Z as an audiobook and it just didn't hit for me. The different voice actors were too distracting, took me right out of the story. Reading it myself I can picture the panic and chaos way better because my brain fills in the tone. Project Hail Mary is actually a good example of the opposite too - those musical notes are just as weird and interesting on the page as they would be spoken aloud. Maybe horror needs that quiet, personal space to really sink in, not someone else's performance telling you how to feel about every line.
-1